Was Nosferatu Antisemitic?
When the Empusa reaches the German town of Wisborg, almost everyone aboard is dead. The ship has carried Count Orlok from Eastern Europe, along with coffins and rats. Soon the streets fill with funeral processions. The townspeople believe a plague has arrived, although the audience knows that something far more disturbing has come ashore.
It is among the most memorable sequences in F. W. Murnau’s Nosferatu, released in 1922. Max Schreck’s vampire scarcely resembles the elegant aristocrat popularized by later adaptations of Dracula. He is bald and gaunt, with pointed ears, protruding teeth, long fingers, and a body that seems almost insectlike. His appearance has become so familiar that it is easy to forget how unusual it was.
Some scholars see another disturbing possibility in that image. Orlok comes from the East, brings rats and disease into a German town, and gains his foothold through dealings with a local estate agent. His grotesque appearance and the devastation surrounding him recall stereotypes used in antisemitic propaganda. The comparison becomes particularly striking beside the notorious Nazi film Der ewige Jude (1940), which portrayed Jews as vermin spreading contamination.
Nosferatu was released eighteen years before that propaganda film. Murnau and his collaborators were adapting a vampire novel published in 1897 while drawing on older folklore, occult traditions, and the fears of a Europe recently devastated by war. Its possible antisemitic associations have to be understood within that earlier setting, alongside the choices made in the screenplay and the film itself.
What an Audience in 1922 Might Have Recognized
Antisemitism was deeply established in European culture long before Hitler came to power. During plague outbreaks, medieval Christians had falsely accused Jews of poisoning wells, as well as committing ritual murder and using Christian blood. By the nineteenth century, older religious accusations were joined by racial and nationalist ideas. Popular caricatures exaggerated Jewish facial features and associated Jews with greed, financial manipulation, or an allegedly alien population working against the nation.
Germany and Austria also had political movements that targeted Jews arriving from Eastern Europe. In antisemitic discourse, Ostjuden, or Eastern European Jews, were associated with poverty, speculation, disease, and unwanted immigration. After World War I, these prejudices circulated amid disputes over housing, food shortages, national decline, and the future of the new German republic. The German publication of The Protocols of the Elders of Zion in 1920 helped spread another falsehood: the claim that Jews secretly coordinated a conspiracy to dominate society.
Parts of Nosferatu could certainly have called these prejudices to mind. Orlok comes from the East and establishes himself in a German town through a property transaction. He appears physically alien, and his arrival is followed by an epidemic that threatens the community. Whether those elements were intended as Jewish markers, reflected stereotypes absorbed from the surrounding culture, or arose chiefly from gothic horror is harder to establish.
Antisemitic accusations linking Jews with disease, blood, conspiracy, and supposedly alien physical features were already familiar in 1922. Nazi propaganda would later combine some of those older prejudices with its own increasingly explicit imagery. The notorious use of rats in Der ewige Jude belongs to that later history and cannot simply be read backward into Nosferatu. The newspaper Der Stürmer, founded in 1923, was likewise too late to have influenced a film completed the previous year. The older stereotypes provide a legitimate basis for comparison, but the visual language of 1940 cannot stand in for the cultural references of 1922.
A Vampire, a Property Deal, and a Conspiracy
Nosferatu was an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s Dracula. Screenwriter Henrik Galeen changed the characters’ names, moved the destination of the vampire’s journey to a fictional German port, and reshaped the story. Jonathan Harker became Thomas Hutter, Dracula became Orlok, and Hutter’s employer became Knock. More significantly, the vampire’s arrival became a public catastrophe: rats and plague engulf Wisborg, while Ellen ultimately sacrifices her life to destroy the monster.
Galeen also combined elements of two characters in Stoker’s novel. Harker’s employer, Mr. Hawkins, and the institutionalized Renfield became aspects of Knock, the estate agent who sends Hutter to Orlok’s castle and seems to be under the vampire’s influence. An apparently respectable local figure thus helps a dangerous outsider enter the community.
Art historian Jürgen Müller built an extensive political interpretation around these changes. In his 1999 study, Der Vampir als Volksfeind, he argued that the film’s screenplay, advertisements, and imagery could be understood as a concealed antisemitic narrative. Orlok threatens the German town, Knock helps bring him there, and the crowd’s pursuit of Knock becomes, in Müller’s reading, a response to devastation supposedly caused by a Jewish conspiracy. Müller connected this pattern to hostility toward Eastern European Jews and antisemitic political language in the early Weimar Republic.
Müller’s argument deserves more attention than a simple comparison between Orlok’s face and a caricature. He examined changes made to Stoker’s novel, the film’s advertising, and material circulating before its release. He also acknowledged that Orlok cannot be equated with the figure of the “eternal Jew” with certainty. The question he raised was whether a contemporary viewer could have assembled the film’s motifs into an antisemitic interpretation.
Müller went further, suggesting that the screenplay had originally been planned as a deliberately antisemitic campaign whose message would remain implicit. His case for that purpose rests chiefly on the arrangement of motifs and narrative choices; the motifs themselves are easier to demonstrate than a concealed intention behind them. One character in the screenplay makes the proposed conspiracy particularly difficult to unravel: a Jewish innkeeper encountered on Hutter’s journey.
The Jewish Innkeeper in Galeen’s Screenplay
As Hutter travels toward Orlok’s castle, he stops at an inn. Galeen explicitly identifies the innkeeper as Jewish and describes him as small, elderly, and hunchbacked. The man is frightened when Hutter mentions Orlok; later, he holds the coach because Hutter has not yet joined the other passengers.
The innkeeper appears in the finished film, played by Guido Herzfeld, but the screenplay’s explicit identification of him as Jewish is absent from the intertitles. A character description written for a screenplay would not necessarily be communicated to a silent-film audience, so the missing label offers little basis for inferring what the filmmakers wanted viewers to recognize.
The character’s conduct is also open to interpretation. He may simply be a frightened local man concerned about a traveler. Müller argues that, in the screenplay, the innkeeper helps move Hutter toward danger and could have served as another connection between Knock and Orlok. He sees the finished film’s warning scene as softening that implication. Yet holding a coach for a missing passenger gives us no reason to conclude that the innkeeper knows Orlok’s plans. The screenplay never identifies him as a conspirator.
Galeen’s physical description nevertheless deserves attention. Even a frightened or helpful character can be described through familiar stereotypes, especially when the writer explicitly identifies him as Jewish. Galeen himself is widely identified as Jewish, and Alexander Granach, who played Knock, was Jewish as well. Their participation does not settle the question in either direction. Jewish artists could reproduce prejudicial conventions that circulated around them, while relationships with Jewish colleagues would not make a director incapable of using antisemitic imagery. Their involvement does, however, complicate any straightforward account of an intentionally anti-Jewish production.
The screenplay gives us a named Jewish character, but no unambiguous Jewish identity for Orlok or Knock and no demonstrated conspiracy involving the innkeeper. That is a problem for the strongest version of Müller’s argument, even if the character’s description raises questions of its own.
What Do the Occult Letters Actually Say?
Müller found another possible clue in the strange documents exchanged by Orlok and Knock. Their letters contain unfamiliar marks, numbers, and figures. Galeen described the writing as incorporating Kabbalistic signs, and the film’s designer and producer, Albin Grau, was deeply interested in occultism. Such imagery had an obvious place in the world Prana Film was creating.
In his 1999 article, Müller identified what he interpreted as a Star of David in a document seen by Knock and a swastika in a different document. He compared the latter to a German antisemitic election poster from 1920, when the swastika was already being used by antisemitic political movements.
The correspondence shown to Knock, the documents seen by Orlok, and the vampire book consulted elsewhere in the film are separate objects. A surviving production title list mentions a pentagram in the Vampyrbuch, while Müller’s proposed Star of David appears in the letter seen by Knock.
The proposed symbols also have histories beyond antisemitic politics. Hebrew letters and six-pointed stars appeared in Western esoteric systems as well as Jewish traditions, while the swastika had several uses before and during the early twentieth century. Grau’s occult interests provide a plausible reason for borrowing from this visual vocabulary. Müller’s political reading is possible, but identifying a familiar symbol does not establish that it was meant to signal a Jewish conspiracy.
The War, the Spider, and the Vampire
Grau and Enrico Dieckmann founded Prana Film with plans to make supernatural and occult pictures. In publicity associated with Nosferatu, Grau recounted a World War I episode in which a Serbian farmer supposedly told him that a dead relative had returned as a vampire. The story suited the film’s promotional campaign, but it also shows the kind of folklore Grau wanted audiences to associate with the picture.
Elsewhere, Grau compared the destruction of World War I to the work of a vast vampire consuming human lives. Germany had experienced defeat, mass death, political upheaval, and the influenza pandemic. A monster whose arrival brought destruction to an entire town could speak to those experiences without depending on a narrowly ethnic allegory.
According to another account by Grau, quoted by Müller from the December 1921 issue of Filmecho, the idea for a vampire film arose when members of Prana’s circle watched a spider consume its prey. The story fits the finished film. Professor Bulwer lectures about predatory organisms, including carnivorous plants and creatures that feed on other life. Orlok’s claws, teeth, and movements place him close to this unsettling natural world of consumption. His famous shadow seems to detach itself from a human body and become a grasping creature.
Predation and parasitism were also part of antisemitic propaganda, so the war and spider imagery cannot dismiss that reading. They do give us other documented sources of meaning for the film. Folklore, epidemic anxiety, occultism, and the recent war were all part of the production’s world, and an interpretation that assigns every disturbing detail to a single political message has to account for them.
Did Anyone Recognize the Allegory in 1922?
The film had screenings in the Netherlands in February 1922 before its formal Berlin premiere on March 4. Prana mounted an elaborate publicity campaign, and contemporary reviewers discussed its photography, atmosphere, performances, effects, and supernatural subject matter. Gary D. Rhodes has collected a substantial sample of those German responses in Vampires in Silent Cinema.
The contemporary responses gathered by Rhodes do not explicitly identify Orlok as Jewish or describe Nosferatu as an antisemitic allegory. Reviewers were much more interested in its uncanny imagery and its place among the supernatural films of the period. Their silence cannot tell us what every audience member recognized, but it gives little support to the suggestion that the alleged allegory was obvious at the time.
There was political criticism. A March 1922 report in the Leipziger Volkszeitung suspected that powerful economic interests were using occult entertainment to divert public attention from political realities. The writer saw a political dimension to the film’s promotion, but the report does not identify an anti-Jewish allegory.
The more sustained scholarly argument emerged decades later. Anton Kaes raised antisemitic structures and motifs in the early 1990s, and Müller developed his case in 1999. Scholars including Marie Mulvey-Roberts and Molly Harrabin have since considered racialized outsiders and antisemitic associations in vampire cinema. Thomas Koebner has challenged attempts to read Nosferatu too directly through later Nazi imagery, while earlier influential historians such as Siegfried Kracauer and Lotte Eisner emphasized different political and aesthetic meanings. The debate is legitimate, but neither contemporary reception nor subsequent scholarship supports treating an antisemitic allegory as the film’s obvious, universally recognized meaning.
Was Nosferatu Antisemitic?
There are good historical reasons to examine Nosferatu through the antisemitism of its time. The foreign outsider who brings contamination into a German community resembles prejudices circulating in the early Weimar Republic. Müller’s argument is especially useful because he goes back to the screenplay, the publicity, and the culture surrounding the film. Some of those details deserve to make viewers uncomfortable.
I find the interpretation plausible as a reading of parts of the film’s imagery. I am much less persuaded by the stronger claim that Nosferatu was planned as a concealed antisemitic political campaign. Orlok and Knock are never identified as Jewish in the screenplay. The innkeeper who is identified as Jewish occupies an ambiguous role, Müller’s proposed reading of the occult letters is open to other explanations, and the contemporary responses gathered by Rhodes do not suggest a widely recognized anti-Jewish allegory. Grau’s own interests in war, predation, folklore, and the occult also offer substantial explanations for the imagery.
None of this requires us to imagine the filmmakers were untouched by the prejudices of their society. An image can echo an antisemitic stereotype without every member of a production consciously intending it to do so. A modern viewer may also recognize disturbing similarities to later Nazi propaganda, provided we do not project that later imagery backward and treat the resemblance as evidence of a plan in 1922.
Orlok remains an unsettling figure partly because the film gives him more than one source of terror. He brings death into a town already recognizable to its audience, and his body seems to belong as much to the world of predatory creatures as to the supernatural. The antisemitic associations deserve examination alongside the war, disease, and occult traditions that shaped Nosferatu. On the evidence presently available, the case for those associations is considerably stronger than the case for a deliberate antisemitic campaign.
Selected sources
Henrik Galeen, Nosferatu screenplay, reproduced in Lotte H. Eisner, Murnau (University of California Press, 1973), pp. 115–156.
Jürgen Müller, “Der Vampir als Volksfeind: Friedrich Wilhelm Murnaus Nosferatu,” Fotogeschichte 19, no. 72 (1999): 39–58, especially pp. 48–51.
Jürgen Müller, “Spinnennetz und Schattenbild,” in Phantome der Nacht: 100 Jahre Nosferatu (2022).
Molly Harrabin, “Racially Profiled? ‘Jewish’ Vampirism in Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau’s Nosferatu (1922),” Studies in European Cinema 21, no. 3 (2024): 287–298; published online June 15, 2023.
Gary D. Rhodes, Vampires in Silent Cinema, chapter 6 (Edinburgh University Press, 2023).
Cristina Massaccesi, Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror (2016); Kevin Jackson, Nosferatu (1922): Eine Symphonie des Grauens (2013); Marie Mulvey-Roberts, Dangerous Bodies (2018).