Sybil: The treatment records behind psychiatry’s most famous multiple-personality case
“What about mamma?” Dr. Cornelia Wilbur asks her patient during a session in the early 1960s. Shirley Mason is lying on a divan in a trance. “What's mamma been doing to you, dear? I know she's given you the enemas. And filled your bladder up with cold water, and I know she used the flashlight on you, and I know she stuck the washcloth in your mouth, cotton in your nose so you couldn't breathe. What else did she do to you? It's all right to talk about it now.” Shirley describes her mother slapping her and warning her not to tell. Wilbur assures her that her mother will never hurt her again. “Do you want to know something, Sweety? I'm stronger than mother.”
The conversation survives in a transcript among the papers of writer Flora Rheta Schreiber at John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York, along with treatment notes, correspondence, and diaries. Many of the original session tapes no longer exist. Journalist Debbie Nathan spent years examining the surviving material for her 2011 book, Sybil Exposed.
Schreiber's Sybil, published in 1973, presented Shirley under the name Sybil Dorsett. It told of a woman whose mind had divided into sixteen personalities to survive severe childhood abuse and of the psychiatrist who spent eleven years uncovering the personalities and bringing them together. The book sold more than six million copies in the United States within four years, and a 1976 television film was seen by an audience estimated at one-fifth of the American population.
Nathan reports fewer than two hundred published cases before Sybil, often involving one or two alternate identities and little resemblance to Schreiber's elaborate account of recovered abuse memories. The book's enormous popularity helped change how multiple personality disorder was understood, both by the public and within psychiatry. Interest in the condition grew, and in 1980, multiple personality disorder was included in the American Psychiatric Association's DSM-III.
Shirley's suffering began long before she became Sybil. She grew up in Dodge Center, Minnesota, in a Seventh-day Adventist family. Her father worked as a builder, and people who knew her mother later described a nervous, overprotective woman, sometimes odd in her behavior.
Shirley was imaginative, invented stories and companions as a child, and later struggled with pain, fainting, exhaustion, menstrual difficulties, confusion, and episodes of losing time. Doctors of the period often described such symptoms as hysteria.
After training as an art teacher and working in mental hospitals, Shirley met Wilbur during a handful of psychiatric appointments in Omaha. She became deeply attached to the young doctor. When Wilbur left for New York, Shirley remembered those meetings for years. In 1954, she moved to New York for graduate study, found Wilbur again, and asked for a few sessions to steady her nerves. Those sessions became eleven years of treatment.
Wilbur had extensive psychiatric training and considerable confidence in a technique called narcosynthesis. Using sodium Pentothal, a barbiturate popularly called “truth serum,” she brought patients into a drugged state and encouraged them to talk. Military psychiatrists had used the technique during the Second World War and had already published warnings about its limitations. Soldiers sometimes produced vivid memories of battles that their service records showed they had never fought, and repeated injections carried a risk of dependence. She also knew the celebrated case that became The Three Faces of Eve, and one of her mentors had treated a patient described as having multiple personalities.
Shirley's first Pentothal session took place in her apartment at the end of 1955. Under the drug, she spoke in a little girl's voice about a trip to Philadelphia. Wilbur called the personality Peggy. Later she identified other changes in Shirley's behavior with other names: anger and fist-pounding belonged to Peggy, a demure manner to Vicky, and prayer and poetry to Mary.
After sessions, Wilbur told Shirley how she had behaved and who had supposedly been speaking. The personalities multiplied over the following years, eventually reaching the sixteen described in Sybil. When Wilbur withheld Pentothal for a period in 1957, Shirley began describing the personalities as parts of herself rather than as separate people, and Wilbur briefly pronounced her integrated. More identities appeared afterward.
Shirley described witnessing a boy named John Greenwald die in a shooting accident when she was seven, supposedly the trauma that caused her first division. Nathan reports that Dodge Center newspapers and Minnesota death records placed Greenwald's death ten years later, when Shirley was seventeen, and that she had not witnessed it. Another memory involved being shut inside a grain crib in her father's workshop; the structure described would not have fit in the workshop. A former teacher later recalled Shirley as a steady pupil, without the marked changes in behavior or academic performance described in the published story. Nathan suggests that some of the assault imagery may have drawn on a childhood tonsillectomy and on enemas associated with health practices in Shirley's Adventist upbringing.
Wilbur administered Pentothal for extended sessions, sometimes leaving the needle in place while she continued questioning Shirley. Other prescribed drugs included stimulants, Demerol, Thorazine, and additional barbiturates. Shirley's difficulties with memory, concentration, and academic work became especially severe during these years. She grew dependent on Pentothal, pleaded for injections in letters, and was hospitalized in Harlem to address the addiction.
In May 1958, Shirley carried a five-page, single-spaced letter into Wilbur's office. “I am not going to tell you there isn't anything wrong,” she wrote. “But it is not what I have led you to believe … I do not have any multiple personalities … I do not even have a ‘double’ … I am all of them. I have been essentially lying.”
She explained that the unusual behavior Wilbur had witnessed in Omaha came from distress at learning that the psychiatrist would be leaving. The trips and episodes of lost time, she wrote, had been attempts to attract attention. She said that the stories about her mother had grown under questioning because Wilbur seemed interested in them. “Under Pentothal,” she observed, “I am much more original.” She described her mother as overanxious but loving, denied the extreme acts attributed to her, and asked Wilbur to help her work out what was actually wrong.
Wilbur treated the recantation as resistance, a psychological defense against memories supposedly being uncovered. Since Shirley could not remember her Pentothal sessions, Wilbur argued that it must have been the other personalities speaking. She continued the treatment, resumed Pentothal, and scheduled frequent appointments. Shirley subsequently wrote another statement blaming the confession on an unnamed personality that had impersonated her.
Herbert Spiegel, a psychiatrist and hypnosis researcher whom Wilbur asked to examine Shirley, found her exceptionally responsive to suggestion and called her a “hypnotic virtuoso.” He met several of the named personalities but regarded them as roles Shirley could assume in trance. On one occasion, she offered him another personality, and he told her to drop it; the role did not recur. Another time he hypnotized her and suggested that she behave like a baby. Wilbur later asked Shirley to name that behavior, and Ruthie became one more of the personalities. Spiegel concluded that Wilbur’s expectations were helping produce identities she took to be autonomous. He made his criticism public in a 1997 interview, decades after examining Shirley.
While Shirley was still in treatment, Schreiber, a writer experienced in covering mental health, wanted the patient's recovery to be complete before she committed to the project. Wilbur assured her that the personalities could be integrated, and in 1965 she declared Shirley cured. The three women formed Sybil, Incorporated, with an agreement to divide the proceeds. The venture contemplated adaptations and merchandise as well as the book itself: a film, board game, dolls, T-shirts, and even a musical.
A 1956 journal entry described Shirley's mother caring for little girls, with Shirley reporting that she had seen nothing improper. In the later account of abuse, the same episode involved sexual activity with children in the woods. Schreiber's visit to Minnesota failed to corroborate some of the abuse stories, and she could not locate the woods where certain events were said to have happened. She raised doubts with Wilbur, who replied that Schreiber was being naïve about the behavior of a sadistic mother, while Shirley complained to Wilbur about Schreiber's questioning. Schreiber proceeded with the book and presented the abuse narrative as fact. Nathan argues that she also invented or altered details to make the story more convincing.
DSM-III described multiple personality disorder as “extremely rare” in 1980. By 1984, proponents were suggesting that as many as 25,000 Americans had the condition, and one estimated three percent of the population, figures not supported by reliable population surveys. DSM-III-R, published in 1987, described the diagnosis as less rare than previously believed and linked it strongly to childhood abuse. The influence of Sybil also reached therapies centered on hypnosis and the recovery of increasingly extreme memories, including some that later became part of the satanic ritual abuse panic. During the 1990s, patients and accused families challenged some of those treatments, and the False Memory Syndrome Foundation was established in 1992. DSM-IV changed the diagnosis's name to dissociative identity disorder in 1994 and cautioned about overdiagnosis among highly suggestible people and the influence of overzealous therapists. The renamed diagnosis remains in the DSM-5-TR.
Under drugs and strong suggestion, Shirley may not always have known how much of her performance was deliberate. Wilbur appears to have believed her diagnosis. Schreiber knew she had encountered contradictions and chose to publish a confident account anyway.
Shirley followed Wilbur to Lexington, Kentucky, taught art, and lived quietly, becoming increasingly reclusive. In their later years the two women lived together, and Wilbur helped arrange Shirley's care after she developed breast cancer. Wilbur died in 1992. Shirley died at home on February 26, 1998, at age 75. Later that year, researchers traced her identity through material connected to the Schreiber archive, and her name became public.
Near the end of her May 1958 letter, Shirley wrote, “I don't know what next … I guess that is up to you.” Wilbur continued treating her as a patient with multiple personalities.
Sources
Debbie Nathan, Sybil Exposed: The Extraordinary Story Behind the Famous Multiple Personality Case (Free Press, 2011).
Debbie Nathan and Michael Snedeker, Satan's Silence: Ritual Abuse and the Making of a Modern American Witch Hunt (Basic Books, 1995).
Flora Rheta Schreiber, Sybil (Regnery, 1973), discussed through Nathan's quotation and archival examination rather than an independent inspection of the complete work.
American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, DSM-III (1980), DSM-III-R (1987), and DSM-IV (1994), as quoted or discussed by Nathan.
American Psychiatric Association, “What Are Dissociative Disorders?”, https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/dissociative-disorders/what-are-dissociative-disorders/ (checked November 2026 for current diagnostic recognition).
Herbert Spiegel, interview with Mikkel Borch-Jacobsen, “Sybil: The Making of a Disease,” The New York Review of Books, April 24, 1997, https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1997/04/24/sybil-the-making-of-a-disease/.